Tuesday, October 8, 2013

Workmanship: Two Sides of the Same Coin (Part 1)

Workmanship n. 1. Skill as a workman; craftsmanship.

Here we have two examples of workmanship from two well known painters. I have chosen these examples for three reasons: 1) they are well crafted but very different in execution, 2) the artists were contemporaries and 3) they were both Dutch painters. The first similarity is the most important while the second two make for a more apt comparison.

Johannes Vermeer, The Girl With the Pearl Earring @ 1665  Collection of the Mauritshuis, the Hague

It is said that Vermeer is more representative of the Dutch tradition of painting with his carefully composed and exquisitely rendered genre scenes. A close up of the painting shows the carefully blended brushwork in the face of the sitter while the turban is done in much broader and defined brushstrokes. 



The painting is a beautiful example of the deceptive simplicity I enjoy in some minor works as its subject has been the cause of great speculation. Who is the Girl With the Pearl Earring? Why did he paint her? What is meant by the juxtaposition of  the modestly covered hair and the sensuality of her mouth? That little is known of Vermeer's life and work adds fuel to the fire. (Having seen several Vermeers in person I can testify that they are definitely worth all the fuss.)  Of course, it is a great pleasure simply to look at the painting, but the mystery of it adds depth to its beauty. 


Part 2, a Rembrandt self portrait: the other end of the spectrum. 

No comments:

Post a Comment